Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-25951143-20150101110046/@comment-26871067-20160928202928

Rez spb wrote: Then keep that to yourself and don't think other trans people are like you. What's your problem, geez. And then people tell like LGBT are all about 'attention' and 'being extravagant'. Because of likes of you they have it that hard, didn't that thought even cross your mind? Maybe you don't want to be equal with others but desire attention, others are not like this one particular you. They just want to lead a regular life, be accepted, and they don't behave like shit because they are (at least my friend is) civilized and modest.

One more reason to not show this thread now, that's a total disgrace. You just said "maybe transgender people are the reason why The Good Transgender People are being oppressed". You are literally a transphobe, spouting transphobic arguments, accusing me of being the bad guy for speaking up in defense of one of the few unabashedly positive transgender characters in media.

And you tell me to be quiet about my own identity as if it's something that's dirty and needs to be hidden. You've already said it in everything but the actual words - you hate transgender people and want us to just go away forever. And you do this by putting words in the mouth of a transgender person who isn't here - who is, Conveniently, not ever going to be here because you, a gallant white knight, a bastion of empathy, don't want her to see this horrible, rude display.

But you'll speak for her, that's fine.

"Keep it to yourself," are you kidding me?

Of course I've become rude, after trying to have a sensible discussion with you and having you ignore every counter to your arguments.

So here's a recap.

You said:

" Yeah, with all that 'boys should inherit family business' stuff so popular in Japan."

I said:

" Killua is the heir of the Zoldyck family, there is no reason for them to be treating a cis daughter as a boy since they have a male heir." Additionally, they have three spare male heirs.

You said:

" The author simply did not think of a gender at manga's earlier stages."

I agreed with this possibility, but noted that it did not mean Alluka wasn't trans.

You said:

"The age of gender identity. How old is Alluka?"

I said:

" When you were 9 you probably knew what your gender was - a trans girl can know she's a girl just as easily as a cis girl. It's different for everyone, of course, but trans kids can absolutely know and many do." Real life transgender kids exist, and know.

You said again, ignoring my responses:

" Again, Alluka's age prevents her being a trans in this kind of a strict family"

Again with the "strict patriarchal family" excuse, which I had already offered a solid rebuttal towards.

You said:

" And while he was thinking about this 'brother-in-concept' and even released first information (Illumi, Silva and other family members calling Alluka 'he' as an example), the character  evolved ."

I said, repeatedly, that there is evidence in the actual text, of the actual story, in the SAME CHAPTERS that call Alluka a girl (via Killua). Here are all the times I said this thing, and every time you acted like they didn't disprove your idea:

"Your argument that this is solely a meta thing (that Togashi changed his mind and decided to make Alluka a female character with a vagina) has counter-evidence in the story itself. The Zoldycks (minus Killua and Alluka), in the "real time" of the story, consider Alluka to be a boy and call her as such. Killua does not. This disconnect is held through the arc past Alluka's first physical appearance."

" There is no character evolution to be speaking of when Alluka being called a boy is happening in the real time of the series at the same time in the series that Killua is calling her a girl. Like, within the same five chapters."

You said:

" I got fed up with that trans-, 'their' and 'correctness' stuff. " " And I really don't like all this trans talk", because that's the real answer to all of this. You don't like trans talk and want all trans people to shut their mouths and never talk about it so you can pretend we don't exist.