User blog comment:Jaadowgg/Special Chapter Review Part 2/@comment-5242743-20121212031411/@comment-48285-20121213064920

@Gojira: That's a pretty interesting theory. However, there are a few problems with it.

1. This is the story of the Kurapika from the movie.

2. Because of fact #1, Chrollo hasn't taken Neon's ability and told the Troupe's future.

3. The fortunes for Shalnark and Shizuku, if I'm remembering correctly, stopped at the end of the current week. Therefore, it was assumed they'd die then. However, things happened that week and they didn't die. Now, I'm not saying those couldn't still happen, it's just that their fortunes turned out to be wrong.

4. Because of fact #1, we don't know if this is what actually happened to the Kurapika from the main story so it's likely that the Clan wasn't killed that way.