User blog comment:Martialmaniac/Enough with Alluka!/@comment-26139711-20150223200114/@comment-5780397-20150223230309

Thank you for being polite despite our opinions being different. There might be a few points I misunderstand about your speech, but I'll try to reply.

First, obviously I chiefly regarded Alluka as a boy in my post, since it is mostly about people calling him a trans. Besides, I do believe he is male, but I concede that we have no "ultimate" proof, although most hints seem to point in that direction.

I have no intention of talking about my sexuality or anything, but I know that gender and sexual orientation are two different things. Still, I do believe he does not think of himself as a boy or a girl, that is what I meant with that sentence. That is the main reason I can't accept that people call him a trans.

Trust me, changing Alluka's gender as "unknown" would not end this discussion (perhaps this has been tried before?), but it would be appropriate to consider it. However, it would be partially incorrect, since we have more hints regarding his gender than with Pitou.

I think I understand your critic to my "acts like a girl". Perhaps I should have said "is feminine", but this could have been viewed as offensive anyway. Still, I needed a way to describe his behaviour. I meant no offense by that: as I said, I don't believe Alluka can discern between "manly" and "womanly" things.

Still. Nothing on Alluka's part suggests he is a trans, only the way Killua calls him, and saying that it's his general conduct that marks him as such goes against all that supporters of this theory have defended so far.

Lastly, do I need to remind that we are talking about a character, an not a true person? No, more important than that, a wiki should contain the most exact information possible, regardless of the fact that it might displease a non-existing person. You mean we should state Alluka is a girl with a boy's body? I think the law defines a person's gender basing on, as awful as it sounds, their genitalia, and objectivity requires that this canon is followed (and again, even if it was not so, Alluka has never claimed "I am a girl" after confirmation from the author came that he is a boy). Contributors should be objective and accurate.

And if it is true that a person's gender does not deine their sexuality, why get so heated up about it in their first place?

Sorry if I have not been clear enough, this is not my first language.