Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-48285-20150629163737/@comment-4896558-20150929111831

Jaadowgg wrote: What's your favorite DC movie from the past couple decades (200-now)?

The Batman Movies by Tim Burton

- Darkchylde wrote: I have been reading more and more hate to our wiki regarding Alluka's gender. What do you think we should do about it?

Well while both sides have in their own sense good arguments, firstly let me point out that some of the death threats and immaturity that has spawned from it has not been all that great, and while there seems to be no end in sight of this case being settles unless, we change Alluka's gender to female. However here are some points on my opinion on the matter that I've come up with: 1. We have feasible evidence that Alluka is male from either the manga or most importantly the most up to date databook. 2. While stated in the manga that Alluka is called a girl, Alluka calls him/herself a girl, it also is said that Alluka is in fact a boy or rather a brother than a sister. 3. This whole matter has simply gone out of control and while our side possibly has the most logical approach, their side does as well, but due to our ruling and standards that makes them all call us transgender haters, we should die, what have you. It makes me lean towards our side more, but then again some shenanigans with images was done on our side as well.

It does however makes me wonder if arguments are held like this in other wikias or forums, to be perfectly honest. Since trans characters is not all that uncommon in either manga or anime, like Gintama, One Piece, hell the anime movie Tokyo Godfathers had a protagonist that was transgender and was a bad-ass in the end. But then there's the case where there's a character that's presented to be a certain gender, but later is "big spoiler" found out to be the opposite gender. A good example of that would be Yagyu Kyubei from Gintama, whom talks like and considers herself a male.

All in all both sides seem restless in saying their opinion/ruling/logic/what have you... is the most conclusive one, but even if it seems to be the most conclusive and truthful, that doesn't all mean in the end it's the right choice, this goes for the both sides. So my opinion would be put Alluka's Gender as Unknown, if both sides truly think they know what Alluka's gender is no matter what conclusive evidence they have, unless someone brings up a reliable/feasible piece of evidence, (Example: The page of the Databook in where Alluka's Gender is mentioned) not a long drawn out argument of what side is correct, or unless Togashi gets better and decides to start up HxH again and somewhere down the line this matter is discussed in the Manga if ever and if not WHO THE HELL CARES!

This entire matter has gone out of control and unless a compromise is held or either one side concedes to the other, than all hope is loss to try and fan out this flame war...

I hope that answers your question and I apologize that it was so long and drawn out... I've held out on my opinion for so long and didn't want to add more wood to the fire and if this starts a flame war here again my apologies.